The type of motivation (and the
subsequent suggestions for strengthening this motivation) that is discussed in
the chapter is not, I believe, the kind of motivation with which my typical
student struggles. The exercises,
advice, and anecdotes that Boice draws upon all revolved around individuals who
already consider themselves “writers,” of a variety of types, and who have
clearly set goals to accomplish with their writing (write a draft of a novel,
meet a deadline for an article, etc).
Therefore, Boice’s task was not necessarily to motivate them “about”
writing or the importance/reason(s) for writing, but to motivate them “to” write,
to do the actual legwork involved in the writing process. I feel that my students need much more
encouragement and assistance with the former type of motivation, and that
motivation of the second kind can only really come after the first has been
established. This is why I have really
enjoyed working with my classes on the first assignment, it (hopefully)
establishes this first level of motivation so that we can then move on to the
kind discussed by Boice i.e. motivation to actually write.
I believe that the following YouTube
video encapsulates this concept, with kittens substituted for students: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdQj2ohqCBk. The kitten inside the box represents a
student who has not yet come to see the importance or significance of writing
i.e. why she should get out of the box; she does not have the proper
motivation. It is this kind of
motivation that we must instill in our students initially, before we can
motivate them to take up the actual writing process i.e. the work the kitten
must do to get out of the box.
I agree, Colin. Boice's article is directed to an audience of writers. Many of our students are coming to us with very narrow, preconceived notions of what writing is--and they're certain they don't like it. But what Kacy said in her post was very telling. Students will say they hate writing, but then they'll enjoy writing a paper on something they're really interested in, or are making a claim they see as genuinely important. It makes me wonder, "Are all high school writing topics prescribed now? Have these students really never been given the opportunity to write on a topic they care about?"
ReplyDeleteWe should talk further in class on the subject of getting the kitten out of the box. Getting students to care about writing is actually a really tricky task.